Morning Coffee ThoughtsSearch MCT
← Back to MCT Commentary

AGITATE AND WEAR OUT

AGITATE AND WEAR OUT

[An MCT Opinion]

Agitate and wear out. Ganyan ang basa ko sa ginagawa ng depensa ni Sara Duterte mula pa sa simula ng impeachment trial. I keep seeing the defense, senators sympathetic to its arguments, and the two Panelos reinforce one another. What I see is a seemingly coordinated effort. The senator-judges trying to get an answer about the evidence keep having to spend time on a different dispute: whether they were right to ask the question in the first place.

Early in the trial, Risa Hontiveros asked the prosecutors to explain why they considered Duterte’s recorded remarks about President Marcos an impeachable offense. The prosecution answered. Alan Peter Cayetano then warned his colleagues about questions that could prejudge the case.

More recently, the defense brought in Chadrin Parian to explain a shoe purchase on Manases Carpio’s credit card. Prosecutor Reynaldo Robles pointed to 24 pairs in a photo for a team of 11 players. Parian agreed that the shoes weren’t exclusively for the children.

When Robles asked about modest living, Pia Cayetano questioned whether buying branded shoes for a public official’s child should count as extravagant. Parian’s answer told me more about the purchase than the argument about what parents should buy their children.

Outside the hearings, there was already a dispute over what Sara Duterte had declared about GenCorp. The company’s lawyer, Suzette Punay, told the court it paid Duterte about ₱2.14 million from 2022 to 2025 as a return of capital. Duterte was absent from GenCorp’s shareholder records. Former presidential legal counsel Salvador Panelo said her declaration was an honest mistake. Prosecutor Chel Diokno rejected that explanation.

Then came the ₱35 million objection. Alexander Cabrera had estimated what it cost to set up five Jollibee franchises. Using a published estimate of ₱35 million per branch, he put the total at ₱175 million and attributed 20 percent to Duterte. That put Duterte’s estimated share at ₱35 million.

Rainer Dela Fuente, a former investigator with the Anti-Money Laundering Council, questioned the research behind the estimate. He said investigators should have visited the sites, talked to people and checked what they found against the paperwork. Cabrera himself had already said he made no written inquiry with Jollibee about the franchise costs.

May punto siya. I would want to know how Cabrera arrived at that number, too.

But when Senator Joel Villanueva asked if the defense had given its witness the Cabrera report, defense lawyer Mark Vinluan said it hadn’t. Vinluan said the defense wanted to question Dela Fuente in open court and avoid contacting him beforehand. So the lawyers showed him parts of the report in court and asked for his opinion.

Kayo ang nagdala ng expert. Ang dating tuloy, sapat na raw na expert siya. Tiwala na lang tayo. Kaya tama lang na tanungin ni Raffy Tulfo kung gaano kabigat ang puna niya sa report na hindi niya nabasa nang buo.

Camille Villar argued that Dela Fuente could explain general accounting principles without seeing the records and asked that he be given time to answer. Chel Diokno questioned the relevance of the money-laundering line of inquiry to the unexplained-wealth allegation. Escudero let the defense pursue it, pointing out that the prosecution itself had presented Anti-Money Laundering Council evidence.

During Dela Fuente’s testimony, Vinluan asked to play about seven minutes of Miriam Defensor Santiago questioning the withdrawal of impeachment articles during Renato Corona’s trial. Diokno objected that the circumstances of the withdrawals differed. Escudero asked for a shorter version. Once the clip started, Erwin Tulfo questioned what it had to do with Duterte’s case.

Vinluan also played a clip of Corona alleging that government agencies had been used against him and his family, then asked Dela Fuente about the use of anti-money-laundering information for political persecution. Another clip showed Rodrigo Duterte opposing an impeachment move against then-Vice President Leni Robredo. Alan Peter Cayetano asked his colleagues to give the defense room to answer the financial evidence the prosecution had brought in.

Paolo Panelo took the argument outside the hearing. He used the Corona comparison to accuse the government of using institutions to go after Duterte for political reasons. Then he singled out Risa Hontiveros, Kiko Pangilinan and Raffy Tulfo. To him, their questions about the witness sounded like the work of prosecutors.

Doon ako napapagod.

The next morning, the Senate impeachment court took up Panelo’s accusation against the senators who questioned Dela Fuente. Erwin Tulfo moved to have Panelo explain his remarks, and presiding officer Francis Escudero granted the motion without objection.

Villar and Alan Peter Cayetano argued for giving the defense room inside the hearing. Salvador Panelo offered an explanation for Duterte’s GenCorp disclosure in public. Paolo went after the questioning itself. Michael Poa, speaking for the defense panel, said the senator-judges had the right to ask questions. The court pushed back with the show-cause order. It still had to take time to do it.

The dispute put the Anti-Money Laundering Council’s work under a different kind of scrutiny, too. Its records were before the court as evidence. The Corona comparison and Paolo Panelo’s accusation asked the public to look at the use of those records as possible political persecution. That put the motives of the institutions using the records into the argument alongside what the transactions actually showed.

Reporters had a new dispute to cover. On the night of the hearing, ABS-CBN reported on what Dela Fuente had read and ran a separate story on Panelo’s accusation. The next day, the show-cause order became a story of its own. Those were real developments. They also gave the fight over the judges’ conduct another day of coverage while the financial questions remained open.

Later that day, Imee Marcos asked Board of Investments official Ceferino Rodolfo whether his agency had seen signs that Cale88, the banana-chip exporter linked to Carpio, was fictitious or had inflated its export figures. He said it hadn’t. When Marcos asked if that meant the business model was plausible, Rodolfo said he couldn’t make that judgment. The defense had brought him in to answer Cabrera’s criticism of the business.

Escudero had already asked whether the income had been declared correctly, even if the company was operating. Win Gatchalian later put about ₱208 million in audited sales alongside about ₱776 million in inward remittances he cited from Anti-Money Laundering Council records. Money coming into an account can include more than payments from customers. Rodolfo couldn’t explain the gap from the documents his agency had.

Lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro accused the defense of dragging out its presentation. Defense lead counsel Sheila Sison said the dates had been announced that day and her next witnesses were unavailable on November 26 and 27. The court moved the next hearing to December 1. Earlier that day, the prosecution agreed to facts about Cale88’s product registration, and the defense dropped its planned trade-promotion witness.

The strategy is already working. The senator-judges are still asking questions. But they have had to stop over the relevance of footage from another trial, take up a public accusation against their own members, and then get back to what the evidence shows. That is extra work for the same people who still have to weigh Cabrera’s estimate and make sense of the Cale88 records. The longer they have to keep bringing the hearing back to the evidence, the more of the court’s time the dispute over its own questioning takes up.

Bakit napunta pa tayo sa kung sino ang may karapatang magtanong?

SOURCES

  1. DZRH News, https://www.dzrh.com.ph/post/cayetano-urges-senator-judges-to-avoid-prejudicial-questions-in-vp-duterte-impeachment-trial
  2. ABS-CBN News, recording of Hontiveros’s July exchange, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMRiBpUywp0
  3. GMA News, https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/1009274/pia-cayetano-frustrated-over-prosecution-s-questions-on-carpio-s-p256k-shoes-purchase/story/
  4. ABS-CBN News, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/19/defense-challenges-report-alleging-duterte-s-p817-m-undeclared-wealth-1659
  5. DZRH News, https://staging.dzrh.com.ph/post/witness-admits-no-written-inquiry-with-local-fast-food-chain-on-gencorp-franchise-costs
  6. GMA News, November 19 hearing recording, https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/video/liveevents/768568/live-impeachment-trial-of-vp-sara-duterte-day-44-nov-19-2026-gma-news-special-coverage/video/
  7. The Philippine Star, https://qa.philstar.com/headlines/2026/11/20/2571371/persecution-vp-defense-shows-corona-trial-videos
  8. November 19 hearing transcript with video timestamps, https://tordecilla.github.io/duterte-impeachment-working-draft/sessions/44/
  9. Philippine News Agency, https://www.pna.gov.ph/article/show-cause-order-issued-vs-vp-sara-spokesperson-over-attacks-on-senator-judges
  10. TV5 News, https://news.tv5.com.ph/politics/read/impeach-court-issues-show-cause-order-vs-vp-sara-spox-panelo
  11. ABS-CBN News, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/20/tensions-flare-over-cale88-as-prosecution-defense-clash-in-vp-duterte-impeachment-trial-2259
  12. ABS-CBN News, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/20/cale88-s-business-operations-under-scrutiny-in-sara-duterte-impeachment-trial-2230
  13. November 20 hearing transcript with video timestamps, https://tordecilla.github.io/duterte-impeachment-working-draft/sessions/45/
  14. ABS-CBN News, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/20/luistro-defense-dragging-presentation-of-evidence-in-impeachment-trial-2227
  15. ABS-CBN News, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/20/impeachment-trial-to-resume-in-december-1920
  16. GMA News on the Santiago, Corona, and Rodrigo Duterte footage, https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/1010060/vp-sara-s-team-shows-duterte-santiago-corona-clips-relevance-questioned/story/
  17. TV5 News on objections to the footage, https://news.tv5.com.ph/politics/read/senator-judges-prosecution-question-use-of-coronas-impeach-trial-videos
  18. GMA News on Punay’s GenCorp testimony, https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/1009095/sara-duterte-had-loose-investment-in-gencorp-received-p2-14m-witness/story/
  19. Pilipino Star Ngayon on Diokno’s response to Salvador Panelo, https://www.philstar.com/test-microsite-clone/police-metro/2026/11/15/2570242/p214-milyon-bayad-ng-gencorp-kay-vp-sara-di-honest-mistake-diokno
  20. ABS-CBN News Day 45 liveblog, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/20/live-updates-vice-president-sara-duterte-s-impeachment-trial-day-45-0959
  21. GMA News on the hearing reset, https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/1010235/sara-duterte-trial-dates-on-nov-26-and-27-reset-over-defense-witnesses-unavailability/story/
  22. ABS-CBN News on the questioning of Dela Fuente, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/19/senator-judges-question-duterte-defense-witness-over-financial-report-2225
  23. ABS-CBN News on Paolo Panelo’s accusations against the senator-judges, https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2026/11/19/panelo-accuses-senator-judges-of-acting-like-prosecutors-in-duterte-s-impeachment-trial-2318

GOOGLE PREFERRED SOURCES

FOLLOW MCT ON GOOGLE

Google’s Preferred Sources feature lets you choose publications you want Google to prioritize for you. Select “Add to Preferred Sources” to make MCT easier to find in Top Stories and other eligible Google results. This does not subscribe you to email.